The following article Soy- Miracle food or Hazard, was recently featured in The John’s Hopkins Magazine – Winter 2011.
Soy has been promoted as a miracle food, after all it is low in fat and has no cholesterol. Researchers thought it might decrease breast cancer risk, minimize hot flashes, and increase bone density in women. Then came soy’s backlash.
Dr. Bruce Trock , director of epidemiology division at the Brady Urological Institute, states that soy foods are fine, soy supplements can be hazardous and should be watched. “None of the studies that have looked at normal consumption of soy foods have given any indication of risk, as long as people are trying trying to get their soy from dietary sources, eating things like tofu, soy milk, soy nuts, miso soup etc.” He states it is unlikely that people will experience any real risk from dietary sources. A study recently presented at the American Association for Cancer Research earlier this year, looked at data from more than 18,000 breast cancer survivors, concluded that women can eat soy foods without increasing their cancer risk.
Trock reports the soy supplements can be dangerous because many are highly processed, which might change the biological activity of the soy product. In several animal studies, soy supplements caused an increase in tumor growth, another study found that the more processed the soy product was, the more it increased the rate of growth in tumors of lab animals. With supplements it is possible to get individual nutrients in very high dosages and of different proportions than you would from eating soy foods.
Here’s the deal, soy’s micronutrient, our body uses micronutrients in small doses, and they don’t just work alone, they work in combination with other micronutrients. It not just about the dosage of one micronutrient, but about the balance of micronutrients, Trock says.






